I've been driving my '00 Frontier Desert Runner V6, 2x4 since I bought it new a decade ago. Back then I was living in VA and the main reason I bought it is so I could throw my bike in the bed and drive to the trailhead which was 40-50 minutes away. It was great for that purpose and the occasional hauling of miscellaneous stuff. I didn't mind the gas mileage since gas back then was cheap. I had no issues with the rear only drive, since I rarely encountered snowy/mucky driving conditions at the time.
I've moved from east coast to west halfway through ownership and still didn't have issues with the 2x4 in NorCal or later in Sandy Eggo. Gas prices did start to rise but that was a non-issue since I started to bike commute or I'd either take Caltrain or split lanes (miss that) riding my dual-sport moto on 101 to work which averaged 45-50mpg. I still used the truck to throw my bike in the bed and drive to the trail head.
Now, I live in Deutschland and brought my truck over. I can tell you that it's not an ideal vehicle here. Gas prices are high, it can't keep up with the Germans on the autobahn (not that I'm really trying to - it's a truck!), even though it's a compact truck it's hard to maneuver and park in the small European villages and parking spots/garages. There's no weight over the drive axle, I don't have a LSD on the rear and even with M&S rated tires, driving in the snow is exciting and raises the pucker factor. Again, outside of the winter, I've been bike commuting to work so I only drive when I really need the truck. In the winter, like now, I ride the bus or train to commute work. Public transportation here in Germany is way better in the US. I've even used it to get to some trail heads. I get maybe 17mpg and I think that really sucks and definitely want something better.
Basically, my needs have changed since I bought my truck. If I were to do it again, I'd go for one of the newer all-wheel drive compact cross-over SUVs like the Nissan Juke or Jeep Compass. I need more enclosed cargo space, seating for four adults, 4x4 or all-wheel drive capability and better gas-mileage. I might even consider the Toyota FJ and take the hit in lesser MPG but gain the better cargo capacity and true 4x4 capability.
So here are the contenders that are under consideration to replace my Frontier. First on the list is the 2011 Nissan Juke. It's a visually striking vehicle. It's styling reminds me of the rallye racing cars of the Dakar - very cool! The front fascia, the two-door fastback lines and overall look really appeal to me. The direct injected 1.6 liter four valve turbo-charged 4 cylinder engine produces more power and is more fuel efficient than my 3.3 liter V6. Nissan is giving out a 27 city / 32 hwy MPG rating for the CVT transmission model. This one is definitely at the top of the list.
Next we have the 2011 Jeep Compass which gets a remodel from the front bumper back to about the B-pillar. It sorta gives it a mini-Grand Cherokee look which I think looks tens times better than the previous incarnation with it's round headlights and awkward body lines. The proportions of the rear seem to provide more rear cargo room unlike the Juke with it's fastback profile. Along with the new body style, Jeep has also given the Compass a "Trail Rated" badge which means more off-road capability over its competitors. I also like the look of this cross-over and it also gets a similar MPG rating from it's inline 4 engine as the Juke.
Finally, there's the 2011 Toyota FJ Cruiser. This one really doesn't fit the vehicle specs I was looking for - small cross-over, I-4 and good MPG rating - but I really liked the unique styling and true 4x4 capability of the FJ. It's been out for a couple of years so the usual first production teething problems are sure to be gone. Toyota has slowly refined the FJ and it really shows in its specs. It's quite larger than the previous cross-overs and this truck has a not-so-great-with-MPG V6 but gains in horsepower and torque, 260/271 ft lbs. I'm really drawn to the FJ because its three-door configuration, styling and capabilities. I just don't know if I want to give up my requirement for better MPG.So those are the vehicles I'm considering to replace my Frontier. Why no European brands like the Mercedes GLK, Audi Q5, or Volkswagen Tiguan? Because when you start to option out them out with what you want, the cost to value ratio really sucks. I mean, really, it's a vehicle you drive around in. I'd rather splurge my coin on something that I really enjoy like cycling!
footnote - While we're on the subject of trucks - here are two previous SUV/cross-over from the past that I really lusted after.
The first is the Isuzu - remember the old "Joe Isuzu" commercials? - VehiCross from the late 90s-early 00s. It won it's class in the 1998 edition of the Paris-Dakar race. It was a rather unique looking SUV back then, probably explaining its short production run. I really liked the rallye racing styling it had.
The Toyota RSC, "Rugged Sport Coupe" was solely a concept car which never made production which is sad because I would've traded my first-born for it. The design cues came from the cars from the World Rally Championships. Funny, I seem to gravitate towards vehicles that have the styling from the motorsports series I'm a fan of - WRC and Dakar.


